Winning Pitching Strategies for Ranked Seasons in MLB The Show 25
Prioritize Pitches With MLB The Show 25 Stubs Horizontal Break in MLB The Show 25
The meta strongly favors:
Sinker
Cutter
Sweeping Slider
Slurve
Circle Change
Why?
Because they attack side-to-side PCI movement, which is harder for hitters than purely vertical movement.
If your pitcher doesn’t have at least two horizontal-moving pitches, they’re not meta for Ranked.
Control the Running Game on the Mound
Stolen bases are stronger this year, so controlling runners is part of pitching strategy.
Use Quick Pitching
Mix in quick pitch occasionally to disrupt timing.
Vary Looks
Step-offs
Holds
Pickoffs
Always throw at least one pick when someone reaches +80 speed. Reducing their lead reduces their scoring probability.
Manage Pitcher Stamina Like a Pro
Tired pitchers leave balls over the plate. MLB The Show 25 penalizes stamina more aggressively.
Rules for Stamina Management
Remove SP after 85–95 pitches depending on control loss
Don’t let relievers face three batters if their confidence is shaken
Warm up relievers early—even in buy MLB Stubs the 4th inning if you're struggling
Know the “3 Batter Drop Rule”:
Once stamina dips past 50%, control worsens drastically over the next three batters. Don’t push past it unless it’s a blowout.