Essential Pro Baserunning Settings
Baserunning Interface: Buttons
While the Analog option feels immersive, Buttons provide consistent, competitive-level control. Using buttons allows you to target runners explicitly. For example, on PlayStation, select the lead runner and press Triangle to go to 2nd or Square to go to 3rd. On Xbox, the equivalents are Y for 2nd and X for 3rd.
Baserunning Decisions: Manual
Set decisions to Manual to prevent the AI from making questionable choices. This stops scenarios like a slow runner trying to stretch a single into a double. Manual control removes the "automation tax," giving you total command, though it requires attention during tense moments.
Player Lock Interface (RTTS): Fixed Analog
In Road to the Show, the default Directional Analog can cause the camera to jump or make input confusing. Fixed Analog keeps controls traditional, stabilizing the camera and helping you execute precise moves.
Advanced Baserunning Controls
| Action | PlayStation Controls | Xbox Controls |
|---|---|---|
| Advance All Runners | Hold L1 | Hold LB |
| Return All Runners | Hold R1 | Hold RB |
| Advance Lead Runner | Tap L2 | Tap LT |
| Return Trailing Runner | Tap R2 | Tap RT |
| Steal (Individual) | Select runner with L-Stick, then tap L2 | Select runner with L-Stick, then tap LT |
Pro Tips for the Bases
Avoid the Tag: When close to a fielder, slide away from the ball. Use the right stick for hook slides to the left or right to evade tags.
Lead-off Discipline: In player-lock modes, hold the Left Stick away from the pitcher until they start their delivery. This reduces pick-off chances while taking your lead.
The "One Decision" Rule: Don’t spam the advance button. Make one clear decision per runner to minimize mistakes and preventable outs.
Mastering these settings and controls in MLB The Show 26 will give you a major edge. With precise manual control, your runners move smarter, slide better, and take bases like a pro.